Monday, September 01, 2025

Minnesota Tragedy: NOT The Hate That Hate Produced

We are witnessing a fascinating and predictable transformation in the way the political right wing responds to mass shootings. For decades the strategy has been to deflect from any discussion of the kinds of gun control measures needed to reduce or eliminate such tragedies. Deflection responses have typically been along the lines of: (1) let's offer thoughts and prayers for the victims, (2) the shooter was a mentally ill person that no gun restrictions would have stopped, (3) the only real solution is to have more guns in society so that there is always a "good guy with a gun" around and ready to take out the bad guy. 

Those three "arguments" remain prominent in right wing discourse, but in the last few years we have seen a fourth.  It goes like this: "we are experiencing an epidemic of mass shooters who identify as transgender, and as such have been indoctrinated into a violent cult."  The Southern Poverty Law Center and other organizations have tracked how anti-trans rhetoric is used not only to deflect from discussions of gun safety, but also to sell guns. 

Not surprisingly, when the shooter in the most recent and horrific massacre in Minneapolis turned out to identify as trans, the right wing anti-trans hate machine went into overdrive. This is spite of the fact that (1) there is not an "epidemic" of trans violence in America, (2) trans people are more likely to be victims of violence than perpetrators of it, and (3) the Minneapolis shooter had apparently been obsessed with school shooters and Nazism since middle school, a much more likely motivation than gender ideology for the killing spree. 

But just as a thought experiment, let's indulge the right wing fantasy in this post. If trans people are truly becoming more violent and vindictive, what would be the cause of that? Whenever I hear the argument that trans people are inherently violent, I am reminded of Mike Wallace's infamous 1959 television special "The Hate That Hate Produced," a five-part documentary that examined the rise and popularity of the "Black Muslims" led by Elijah Muhammad (leader of the Nation of Islam) and his fiery representative Malcolm X. Even though Wallace provided no evidence that Nation of Islam members had ever committed physical violence against Whites, the message of the program to White viewers was clear: Elijah Muhammad and his followers hate you, want to separate from you, and speak in ways that make violence against you inevitable. 

Unlike the Klan, southern politicians, and other assorted racists, Wallace did not frame Black violence (real or imagined) as something inherent to people of African descent. As Wallace put it in a 1998 interview, "If they felt that hatred, it was in reaction to the hatred that they felt had been directed against them, therefore, The Hate That Hate Produced."

So if, as the right wing fantasies insist, there is a cabal of evil trans activists out there fomenting hate and violence against cisgender people, what might produce that hate?  Imagine being a trans person living in the United States this decade. Consider these facts: 

  • The Human Rights Campaign has been documenting violence against trans people since 2013; attacks against trans people of color, especially, can truly be called an epidemic. 
  • In 2024 the Republican Party spent over $80 million on transphobic political ads. 
  • Hundreds of anti-trans bills have been proposed in state legislatures across the country.
  • In United States v. Skrmetti, the Supreme Court essentially held that the principle that medical treatment is a private matter between the person seeking care, their family, and their doctors applies to everyone except trans youth and their families. 
  • Donald Trump has signed a number of executive orders seeking to ban transgender people from public life. 
  • In August the US Air Force denied early retirement benefits for transgender members with 15-18 years of service, escalating Trump's attempt to rid the military of any trans presence. 

Anti-trans rhetoric, legislation, and scapegoating has had significant impact on public attitudes. As of February 2025, according to Pew Research, 66% of Americans favor laws and policies that require trans athletes to compete on teams that match their sex assigned at birth. Similarly, 56% support laws or policies that ban heath care professionals from providing gender transition care to minors. The most frightening finding, however, is the one that some pro-trans people and allies saw as encouraging: "56% of adults express support for policies aimed at protecting trans people from discrimination in jobs, housing and public spaces."  ONLY 56 percent?(!). Imagine in 1933 a poll of German citizens that found, "56% of adults express support for policies aimed at protecting Jews from discrimination in jobs, housing and public spaces." 

Given all of the above, we might expect that transgender people would be as violent as cisgender men. But that is not the case. 

Make no mistake: hate and cruelty are prominent in the contemporary United States, fomented and acted on from the highest office in the land to local communities. The Minnesota shooter without question was motivated by hate, but the evidence suggests it was a hate driven by identification with fascists and finding in the experience of prior school shooters a model of how to exact vengeance against "enemies" and get media attention while doing it. That kind of hate is all too common in the United States and is not unique to any one social class. To blame the Minnesota tragedy on something intrinsically evil about trans people, or to blame the overall rise in hate and cruelty on the trans population--a group that faces an existential threat--is the most extreme level gaslighting possible. Or as argued by Abby Vesoulis in Mother Jones Magazine, after noting that 134 of the 141 mass shootings tracked by Mother Jones from 1982-2023 were carried out by men with no known history of identifying as trans or nonbinary, "to blame the unnerving prevalence of mass shootings in America on the existence of trans people here isn’t just a dangerously stigmatizing, politically motivated take. It’s also bad math."

Monday, August 11, 2025

Interviews With Mike McCabe

I recently was fortunate to do two interviews with Wisconsin author and democracy activist Mike McCabe for the Media Rants podcast. Mike was executive director of the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign for a number of years. After leaving the organization he wrote a great book: Blue Jeans in High Places--The Coming Makeover of American Politics. He ran a spirited campaign for governor in 2018, earning almost 40,000 votes in the Democratic Party primary. He then wrote another book, Unscrewing America: Hints and Hopes From the Heartland. Mike's most recent book is his first work of fiction: Miracles Along County Q. Mike also maintains a substack called Ebiyan House. 

Part 1 of our conversation is about Miracles Along County Q: 


Part 2 is a discussion of Wisconsin Governor Tony Evers' legacy and Wisconsin politics: 


You can support the Media Rant podcast by subscribing. Go here. 

Friday, August 01, 2025

Ozzy Osbourne and the Liberation of Auden's Unknown Citizen

This post is going to make a connection between the recently deceased rock singer Ozzy Osbourne, his band Black Sabbath, and the late, brilliant British poet W.H. Auden. Trust me, it will make sense. Here goes . . . 

In the early days of so-called "Heavy Metal," four singers were widely recognized as pioneers in the genre:  Robert Plant of Led Zeppelin, Ian Gillan of Deep Purple, Roger Daltrey of The Who, and Ozzy Osbourne of Black Sabbath. To this day, it is hard to find a male metal singer not influenced at least in part by one of these rock gods. [Note: Most critics would not call The Who a heavy metal band. If we were just talking about their studio albums, I would agree. Their live act at the time, however, was literally the loudest in the world and featured the distorted guitar and driving rhythm section characteristic of Metal proper.]. 

Ozzy recently passed away at the age of 76. As front man for a metal band, he was unique in that there were no prior performers to whom he could be directly linked. Plant, Gillan, and Daltrey all gave off vibes that called to mind Little Richard, James Brown, Elvis, Tina Turner, and Mick Jagger (who was himself inspired by the same stars.). 

So what to make of Ozzy? In this post I write only for myself, as someone who was fortunate to engage the music of Black Sabbath when it was at its most raw and vital. At that time (i.e. the mid-1970s) I was in a Catholic High School and, like all teens, struggling to find my way in the world. While discovering Sabbath, I was also into the literature of Herman Hesse and the polemical works and fiction of George Orwell. All three of them, for me anyway, provided comfort for a young person filled with anxiety over the prospect of having to survive in an absurd world that rewards stupidity, scorns independent thought, reduces love to Hallmark card cliches, and induces fear of authority and of the unknown. The fact that Black Sabbath was censored on FM radio at that time only increased my tendency to elevate them to the level of more "serious" poets, pundits, and polemicists. 

My personal fascination with Ozzy had nothing to do with the "Prince of Darkness" and "Madman" brands, both of which struck me as nonsensical, music industry hype to sell records, merchandise, and concert tickets. My guess is that Ozzy too, in the early days at least, was at best amused by his public image. Unfortunately his alcoholism and drug addiction made it difficult, for most of his adult life, for him to take full control of his persona and personal narrative.   

For those of us who bothered to listen to Black Sabbath in their classic period (1969-1975), there was  something quite profound going on in the music. The metal genre, with its loudness and distortion, mimics a chaotic environment that any working class person can identify with. When I learned that Sabbath were from Birmingham, England--a distinctly working class town--their music made even more sense to me. I have no idea what the band THOUGHT they were doing in those early days, but for me Sabbath seemed to be about provoking us working class folks to reflect on the depravity of our condition and the social forces that create it. Ozzy did not write all or even most of the lyrics back then, but it did not matter: his voice was a literal instrument that spanned the emotions of despair, longing, anger, confidence, and ecstasy in ways that few vocalists have ever been able to pull off. Black Sabbath songs are notoriously hard for other bands to cover NOT because of the guitar and rhythm section, but because it's almost impossible to do justice to Ozzy's original vocal interpretations. 

The album that introduced me to Sabbath was Volume 4 (originally released in 1972), which I probably started to get into around 1974 or 1975. Imagine what an alienated teen like me--steeped in Catholic guilt and reading Hesse and Orwell, would have thought when hit with Vol. 4's opening tune,  "Wheels of Confusion": 

Long ago I wandered thru my mindIn the land of fairy tales and storiesLost in happiness I knew no fearsInnocence and love was all I knewIt was an illusion
Soon the days were passing into yearsHappiness just didn't come so easyLife was more than fairy tales and daydreamsInnocence was just another wordIt was an illusion
Lost in the wheels of confusionRunning thru valleys of tearsEyes full of angry delusionHiding in everyday fears
So I found that life is just a gameBut you know there's never been a winnerTry your hardest, you'll still be a loserThe world will still be turning when you're goneYeah, when you're gone


What's particularly brilliant about that song is that after they drop that deep message on you, the song closes with an extended instrumental jam that gives listeners a chance to reflect on what they just heard. 

I then got into Sabbath's first album, which included "Wicked World:" 

The world today is such a wicked thingFighting going on between the human racePeople got to work just to earn their breadWhile people just across the sea are counting the dead
A politician's job they say is very highFor he has to choose who's got to go and dieThey can put a man on the moon quite easyWhile people here on earth are dying of all diseases
A woman goes to work every day after dayShe just goes to work just to earn her payChild sitting by but his life's much harderHe doesn't even know who is his father

Then the Paranoid album, with the classic "War Pigs": 

Generals gathered in their masses
just like witches at black masses
evil minds that plot destruction
sorcerers of death's construction
in the fields the bodies burning
as the war machine keeps turning
death and hatred to mankind
poisoning their brainwashed minds, oh lord yeah!

Politicians hide themselves away
they only started the war
Why should they go out to fight?
They leave that role to the poor

Time will tell on their power minds
Making war just for fun
Treating people just like pawns in chess
Wait 'till their judgement day comes, yeah!

Now in darkness, world stops turning
as she is aware there's bodies burning.
No more war pigs of the power
Hand of god has sturck the hour
Day of judgement, god is calling
on their knees, the war pigs crawling
Begging mercy for their sins
Satan, laughing, spreads his wings
ALL RIGHT NOW!

Then the "Masters of Reality" album with the anthemic "Children of the Grave" 

Revolution in their mindsThe children start to marchAgainst the world in which they have to liveAnd all the hate that's in their heartsThey're tired of being pushed aroundAnd told just what to doThey'll fight the world until they've wonAnd love comes flowing through, yeah
Children of tomorrow live in the tears that fall todayWill the sun rise up tomorrow bringing peace in any way?Must the world live in the shadow of atomic fear?Can they win the fight for peace or will they disappear? Yeah
So you children of the world listen to what I sayIf you want a better place to live in spread the word todayShow the world that love is still alive, you must be braveOr you children of today are children of the grave, yeah
That song is now over 50 years old but it could easily be a Generation Z anthem. 

After Ozzy Osbourne got fired from Black Sabbath in the late 1970s, I pretty much stopped listening to them. The band continued to make some good albums with a number of great singers, most notably Ronnie James Dio and Ian Gillan. But without Ozzy there was something missing, and so I pretty much lost interest. 

Then in graduate school, I just by chance happened to read some of the old works of British poet W.H. Auden. I learned that Auden spent much of his youth in Birmingham, England--where the members of Black Sabbath were from. When I read Auden's poem "The Unknown Citizen" (originally published in 1939), I immediately thought of Sabbath's early records again. 

Here is the full poem: 

W.H. Auden, The Unknown Citizen

(To JS/07 M 378  This Marble Monument Is Erected by the State)

He was found by the Bureau of Statistics to be

One against whom there was no official complaint,
And all the reports on his conduct agree
That, in the modern sense of an old-fashioned word, he was a saint,
For in everything he did he served the Greater Community.
Except for the War till the day he retired
He worked in a factory and never got fired,
But satisfied his employers, Fudge Motors Inc.
Yet he wasn't a scab or odd in his views,
For his Union reports that he paid his dues,
(Our report on his Union shows it was sound)
And our Social Psychology workers found
That he was popular with his mates and liked a drink.
The Press are convinced that he bought a paper every day
And that his reactions to advertisements were normal in every way.
Policies taken out in his name prove that he was fully insured,
And his Health-card shows he was once in hospital but left it cured.
Both Producers Research and High-Grade Living declare
He was fully sensible to the advantages of the Instalment Plan
And had everything necessary to the Modern Man,
A phonograph, a radio, a car and a frigidaire.
Our researchers into Public Opinion are content
That he held the proper opinions for the time of year;
When there was peace, he was for peace: when there was war, he went.
He was married and added five children to the population,
Which our Eugenist says was the right number for a parent of his generation.
And our teachers report that he never interfered with their education.
Was he free? Was he happy? The question is absurd:
Had anything been wrong, we should certainly have heard.

What I found remarkable about that poem was its powerful mockery of the manner in which modern society made humans into "unknown citizens" for whom happiness is a matter of doing what you're told and not rocking the boat. [Notice how Auden dedicated the poem to JS/07 M 378--signifying his revulsion at how modern society reduces us to numbers].  

In my view, early Black Sabbath--like Auden--were angry at this pathetic state of affairs. I did not necessarily think of it this way in my teenage years, but I came to believe that early Sabbath was provoking me to be anything BUT an "unknown citizen." Auden said, "When there was peace, he was for peace: when there was war, he went." What I heard Ozzy saying was, "when there's war, there's war pigs starting it."  

Ozzy Osbourne was many things, but "unknown citizen" was not one of them. The dream of early Black Sabbath, and really all heavy metal at its best, is that none of us will be unknown citizens. Rather, each of us should strike out against the pressures to conform and should instead become KNOWN.  Known for what? For thinking independently and maximizing our individual creativity in whatever we pursue in life. 

In a real sense, early Black Sabbath and Ozzy Osbourne liberated Auden's Unknown Citizen. Thank goodness for Birmingham, England. 

Friday, July 25, 2025

Media Rants Interview With Dr. Chu May Paing

 

Friday, July 11, 2025

New Media Rants Interview: Menasha, WI Mayor Austin Hammond

Tony talks with Austin Hammond, who in April of 2024 became the youngest Mayor in the history of Menasha, WI as well as the first Native-American to get elected to that office. Tony and Austin talk about youth involvement in politics, as well as responsibilities of local government and the challenges that make it difficult to meet them. More information about Menasha: https://www.menashawi.gov/

Tuesday, July 01, 2025

Celebrating the Music of 1975, Part 2

Back in April I identified 25 albums worth celebrating, all of them now 50 years old. Most of these artists and albums I listened to at the time they were released, a time when the general excellence of FM radio empowered record labels to take risks on artists daring to challenge the conventional 2-3 minute pop song format of the AM dial. The purpose of these celebrations is not only to relive my youth, but to expose younger generations to artists and albums that represent the foundational sounds at the root of today's music. Here are links to prior entries in the series: 

And now 25 more albums from 1975:  

#25 Earth, Wind & Fire: That's The Way of the World. Soul giants Earth, Wind & Fire in 1975 gave the world an album that can be described accurately as almost 40 minutes of pure joy. The band's signature song, "Shining Star" was so popular that it overshadowed almost everything else on the album, including the epic title song. "Shining Star" had a resurgence in 1996, when Seinfeld's Elaine Benes created the iconic little kick dance. The song's core message is something that should be taught to children as early as possible: 

You're a shining starNo matter who you areShining bright to seeWhat you could truly be



#24 The Who: The Who By Numbers. Not the best Who album of their classic period, nor even one of my personal favorites. What's special about it is the fact that it is guitarist/songwriter Pete Townshend's attempt to come to grips with his alcoholism and other personal demons. After writing two epic albums about tortured characters ("Tommy" and Jimmy from "Quadrophenia"), Pete finally concluded that his own torture was worthy of artistic treatment. 



#23 The Eagles: One Of These Nights. This was the last Eagles album to feature the band's country-rock sound. The next year guitar hero Joe Walsh would join and send the band in a new, grittier direction. "One Of These Nights" includes "Lyin' Eyes," the late Glenn Frey's greatest song IMHO. 



#22 Harold Melvin & The Blue Notes: To Be True. It's difficult to believe that there was a time when FM rock radio actually played soul groups. The song "Bad Luck" from "To Be True" got extended play on FM rock radio, at least in New York City where I was living at the time. Teddy Pendergrass, whose voice could stop a train, was one of the greatest vocalists in the history of recorded music.  



#21 Elton John: Captain Fantastic & The Brown Dirt Cowboy. Here we get Elton John nearing the end of his classic period. As with so much early 1970s rock-pop, the album is highly autobiographical and personal. Includes the epic "Someone Saved My Life Tonight." 



#20 Joni Mitchell: The Hissing of Summer Lawns. In the early 1970s Joni Mitchell moved beyond her folk-rock foundation and ventured into jazz and other unconventional sounds for 1960s icons. The Hissing of Summer Lawns did not spawn any major radio hits, but it is extraordinarily creative throughout. "The Jungle Line" is one of her most underrated songs. 



#19 Bob Seger: Beautiful Loser. Even though this was Seger's 8th album, it did not break him into the mainstream. That would not happen until the next year's release of "Live Bullet," which featured energetic concert performances of many of the songs on "Beautiful Loser." 



#18 Ritchie Blackmore's Rainbow. When guitar giant Blackmore announced in 1974 he was leaving legendary metal band Deep Purple, the expectation was that his next project would be something substantially unlike a Purple jam. Surprisingly, Ritchie Blackmore's Rainbow debut album in 1975 featured tunes that could have easily been on a Purple album. What makes the album important in rock music history, though, is that it placed singer Ronnie James Dio on the international metal map. A case could be made that Dio is the greatest metal singer in the history of the genre. 



#17 ZZ Top Fandango. In vinyl terms, this album featured a live sidc and a studio side. One of the major records that reminded listeners of the blues roots of rock-and-roll. Helped to establish conclusively that Billy Gibbons was right up there with Hendrix, Clapton, Beck, and Page as the great blues-rock guitarists of the era. 



#16 The Grateful Dead: Blues For Allah. I was never the biggest Dead fan in the early 1970s, but thanks to the heavy play this album received on FM radio, I ended up getting into the band's entire catalogue. "Franklin's Tower" from Blues For Allah remains as one of my all time favorite songs. 



#15 Renaissance: Scheherazade and Other Stories. Just a classic example of the "progressive rock" of the times, which (I know I have written this many times) was only able to be heard because of the excellence of FM radio at that time. Annie Haslam sang with a kind of urgency that you don't hear very much these days, while the band blended classical, jazz, folk and other genres to come up with something unique. "The Vultures Fly High" would be a good resistance anthem for modern anti-fascist movements. 



#14 War: Why Can't We Be Friends? A soul-pop classic. The title song, which should probably be revived in our polarized era, was actually beamed to outer space during a meeting of American and Soviet astronauts. I also remember it being played at Yankee Stadium when legendary manager Billy Martin would come out and kick dirt on an umpire. 



#13 Stanley Clarke: Journey To Love. One of the greatest bass players of all time, Clarke is a foundational figure in jazz fusion. My favorite piece on this amazing album is "Hello Jeff," featuring Clarke's thumping bass and the blistering guitar of Jeff Beck. 



#12 KC & The Sunshine Band: KC & The Sunshine Band. The breakthrough album from one of the most iconic disco bands of the era. In 1974 I was probably too cool to admit to liking this music, but given how modern dance music pretty much all sounds the same, KC somehow sounds fresher fifty years later. 



#11 Frank Zappa & The Mothers of Invention: One Size Fits All. In 1975 Frank Zappa released two of his all time greatest albums. "One Size Fits All" featured a new Mothers Of Invention line-up, including elite musicians like keyboardist George Duke and percussionist Ruth Underwood. The epic song "Inca Roads," in classic Zappa fashion, is kind of a like a satire of the progressive rock of the era. 



#10 Frank Zappa & The Mothers of Invention: Bongo Fury. Vaclav Havel, the Czech playwright and dissident who eventually became president of the Czech Republic, told Zappa that his music was a lifeline when his country suffered under totalitarian rule. He also told him that Bongo Fury was his favorite album. The album is filled with typical Zappa satire, and his guitar solo in "The Muffin Man" is one of the greatest in rock history. Of all the rock stars who have left the Earth, Zappa is the one I most wish was still with us to help resist Trumpism. 



#9  Peter Frampton: Frampton. Guitar hero/vocalist Peter Frampton would attain international superstar status the next year, with his "Frampton Comes Alive" album.  But 1975's "Frampton," which largely flew under the radar, is for me a masterpiece of rock-pop. I especially loved it in 1975 because it seemed to be inspired by the best rock of the 1960s while also revealing a completely original sound. 



#8 Bad Company: Straight Shooter. I would like to dedicate this one to the late guitarist Mick Ralphs, who passed recently and who was one of the shining lights of Bad Company. My favorite song on this album, "Shooting Star," could be about Mick. It's also hard to imagine a rock singer better than Paul Rodgers. 



#7 Donna Summer: Love To Love You Baby. Given the sexual excess of so much modern music, it's difficult to appreciate how racy and scandalous Donna Summer's music was in the 1970s. Literally every dance music star since then owes a debt to Donna. 



#6 The Kinks: Schoolboys In Disgrace. I was not totally into this album when it came out (probably because it deals extensively with boy/girl school relationships and I was in an all boys high school), but have come to look on it very fondly. Ray Davies--guitarist, vocalist, and leader songwriter for the Kinks-- in the 1970s wrote a number of provocative tunes filled with social commentary. "Schoolboys in Disgrace' I think should be given all members of Generation Z as a kind of pop culture evidence of what school was like before cell phones and artificial intelligence.  



#5  Steely Dan: Katy Lied. A transitional album for Steely Dan, written and recorded after Donald Fagen and Walter Becker made the decision to stop touring and instead focus on perfecting the art of studio recording--which allowed them to work with the best session musicians in the world. Katy Lied establishes the sound that, in my view, the band would bring to perfection in the 1977 "Aja" album.  

The song "Throw Back The Little Ones" on Katy Lied includes one of my all time favorite lyrics: "Hot licks and rhetoric don't count much for nothing." As someone who has been teaching Rhetoric for 40 years, that line always hits home! 

My favorite song on Katy Lied has to be "Doctor Wu," which for me is the definitive Steely Dan sound of the period. 



#4 Patti Smith: Horses. Punk rock of the 1970s came to be defined by loud guitars and defiant lyrics. But in the 1970s there was also an "artistic" punk that tried to revive the innovative, bohemian style of 1960s groundbreakers like the Velvet Underground, the Doors, and early Bob Dylan. Patti Smith was in the vanguard of the artistic punk movement, and "Horses" is a foundational recording in the genre. 



#3  Black Sabbath: Sabotage. The last truly great album by Black Sabbath, in my opinion. Features all the original members, and some of Ozzy Osborne's best writing. I have no proof, but I am convinced that literally every song ever recorded by Metallica and other "Nu Metal" bands of the 80s and later was inspired by "Symptom of the Universe." 



#2 Bob Dylan: Blood on the Tracks. Somewhat of a comeback album for Dylan in 1975, though much more deeply personal than anything he had released to that point. When I assign students classic albums to review in my "Rhetoric of Rock and Roll" course, "Blood on the Tracks" is one that often becomes a revelation to the student assigned it. I think that's because the idea of love as a source of great joy and great pain--a theme embedded in Blood on the Tracks--is something that always has and always will connect with youth. 



#1 (Tie) Pink Floyd: "Wish You Were Here" and Kraftwerk: "Radioactivity."  In terms of sheer impact on future music, these two albums would have to be the best of 1975. "Wish You Were Here," which is informally dedicated to the band's founding and troubled member Syd Barrett, is the archetype of the tribute album. Filled with amazing melodies, brilliant instrumentation, thoughtful lyrics. 

As for Kraftwerk's "Radioactivity," it's hard to minimize the influence it had on future music. Modern music fans think that electronic music is a digital era phenomenon. Not so. Kraftwerk did it all--and did it better--50 years ago. 



 

Wednesday, June 25, 2025

Media Rants Interview: Dan Shafer of the Recombobulation Area

 

Monday, June 09, 2025

Recent Media Rants Videos

Some recent Media Rants videos. 

The New York Times appears to be torn between its noble mission of seeking truth and helping people understand the world and the business model of the paper which has Jerry Springer features: 


In his new book, Jake Tapper claims that Democratic Party insiders enabled the declining Joe Biden. Tapper was involved in his own scandalous behavior in 2024:


If you're wondering what you would be doing during the slavery era or other times of great injustice, you're probably doing it now: 

Sunday, June 01, 2025

Challenging A Generation Z Stereotype

Generation Z includes people born between the years 1997 - 2012. We all know the stereotypes: "They're addicted to social media, hate emails, can't be bothered to read, misuse AI tools for homework, and only think about themselves." 

As a college professor teaching students primarily in the Gen Z age range, I've got first-hand experience with all those stereotypes. But with 40+ years of teaching experience, I can't say the challenges Gen Z presents in educational settings are any worse than what I saw from their parents' generations. Different, yes. But not necessarily worse. Since the invention of classrooms (and now online spaces too), distraction and disengagement (D & D) have plagued large numbers of students. Perhaps it is more obvious with Gen Z because, in showing up with phones, laptops, and/or other technologies, their D & D has an "in your face" quality more off-putting than the blank stares of older cohorts. 

As a media critic, one thing I'm told frequently about Gen Z is that they have ZERO regard for so-called "legacy" news media; i.e. the traditional guardians of public knowledge like the New York Times, ABC News, or cable TV outlets like CNN and Fox. Gen Z, we are told, will always prefer to be informed via TikTok videos, Reddit threads, or trendy podcasts.  Even though all of the legacy media have now dedicated significant resources toward adapting to the requirements of grabbing and maintaining attention in the digital age, they are not the first choice for news for most young people.  

Is it true that Gen Z will not engage legacy media, even when presented in a digital format? Recently I decided to test that hypothesis. From March-May of this year, I taught a 7-week, fully online course called "Rhetoric in Action." There were 29 students enrolled, including 25 Gen Zers and 4 millennials (I learned the generational status by asking everyone to share with the class the name of the #1 song on the day of their 10th birthday). The class population included 19 seniors set to graduate in May or December, 8 juniors, and 2 sophomores. There where 19 women and 10 men, and most were Communication Studies majors. 


The Home Page of the Online Syllabus for COMM 388: Rhetoric in Action.
                                                    
A week or two before the official start of the class, all students were contacted and told that they had to subscribe to the online New York Times, as we would be doing a "deep dive" into the paper. 

Approximately two-thirds of the course material required students to do rhetorical analysis of the New York Times. Assignments included: 

  • Critical analysis of a piece of reporting from any of the following sections of the NYT: Arts, Business, Climate and Environment, Education, Food, Health, New York Times Magazine, Parenting, Politics, Science, Style, Technology, Wellness, World. 
  • Critical Analysis of an assigned NYT Opinion Page writer: Students analyzed columns by Jamelle Bouie, David Brooks, Gail Collins, Ross Douthat, Maureen Dowd, David French, Thomas Friedman, M. Gessen, Michelle Goldberg, Nicholas Kristof, Carlos Lozada, Tressie McMillan Cottom, Lydia Polgreen, Bret Stephens, and Zeynep Tufekci.
  • An evaluation of as assigned episode of the New York Times The Daily podcast.
  • An evaluation of the New York Times as a form of visual rhetoric.
  • Two exams covering the course textbook (The Rhetorical Act: Thinking, Speaking and Writing Critically by Karlyn Kohrs-Campbell, Susan Schultz-Husman, and Thomas Burkholder. Cengage Learning, 2015.). 
Approximately one-third of the course required students to "do" rhetoric; to write and speak in ways that would be suitable for publication in the New York Times. Assignments in this section of the course included: 

  • Engaging in an in-depth, written conversation with a classmate about current events. In essence, the students were asked to mimic The Conversation by NYT writers Gail Collins and Bret Stephens. 
  • Writing a 1000-1500 word opinion piece that would be suitable for publication on the New York Times opinion page.
  • Preparing and Recording a 4-6 minute message, designed for the New York Times Editorial Board, with the purpose of persuading the Board to publish the student's 1000-1500 word opinion piece.
Going into the course, the two Gen Z stereotypes I was most concerned about were: "can't be bothered to read" and "misuse AI tools for homework." These ended up really not being major problems. Only 4 of the 29 students were not subscribed to the NYT by the first day of class, and only 1 probably never subscribed.  Scores on the exams were not great, but the exams involved reading the course textbook. Students have been doing poorly on textbook exams since way before Gen Z. 

As far as reading the New York Times, the results were very encouraging. In the assignments that required analysis of NYT articles and writers, I could tell that the clear majority of students had engaged the material as evidenced by their ability to summarize and pull relevant quotes from specific articles. Every student seemed appreciative to have the opportunity to think and write about public issues that do not frequently come up in college classes. 

Emme Hornung was a student in the Rhetoric in Action course. Her insights about what it was like to study the New York Times in an academic setting are fascinating. 

Artificial intelligence abuse did not appear to be a problem. I only detected two blatant attempts to pass off an a AI generated paper as original work, and both students immediately admitted it. Each individual told me that they simply got busy with other classes, work, etc. and used AI just to get done by the deadline. (I allow students the opportunity to redo the assignment with no penalty IF they admit that they used AI without proper citation and/or letting me know in advance why they are using it.). 

For me the most inspiring part of the course was the 1000-1500 word opinion pieces. Before the students wrote them, I did have them each send me a thesis statement and short justification for their choice of topic, which allowed me to provide feedback and ensure that the proposed piece would be appropriate for the NYT. Students wrote on a range of topics dealing with education, media, politics, culture, and other areas. One thing that became obvious, just from the topic choices and style of writing, was that the students had in fact been engaging the New York Times for six weeks.   

I enjoyed all the student opinion pieces, but I will quote from just one. Student Ava Heeringa wrote a piece she titled "Reclaiming Peace In a Digital World." I'm quoting Ava's because her piece powerfully, and in an authentic student voice, contests the idea that Gen Z is not reflective about the digital culture they find themselves mired in. She writes: 

I’m 21 years old, just months away from earning my degree in Communication Studies at a university I’m proud to attend. While I’m optimistic about the future, there’s a quiet anxiety that follows me. One that is fueled by the pressure to be constantly reachable and online at all times. 

This morning, I woke up and immediately checked my phone for any notifications. The day before, I responded to emails while brushing my teeth. Constant digital access is real and I am living proof of it. 

The consequences of this constant connectivity have crept into nearly every corner of my life. Mentally, I experience waves of anxiety throughout the day. It's as though my mind is always on alert, constantly cycling through notifications and tasks that need attention. This has left me feeling mentally exhausted, even when I'm supposed to be relaxed.

Academically, I feel drained and constantly on edge. A single email about homework or a new grade notification can ruin my focus and control my mood. My ability to multitask, once something I was proud of, now leaves me scattered, like I’m doing everything halfway. Professionally, it’s just as overwhelming. Every time my phone buzzes at work, I glance at the screen out of habit. It’s as if I’m on-call all the time. The mental energy I give to my devices each day is exhausting. Yet stepping away feels like I’m breaking an unspoken rule. I know this isn’t a unique experience. It’s part of a cultural shift and a redefinition of what it means to be “available.” 

Students are expected to respond to professors and classmates around the clock, as if class never really ends. The same applies to remote work, where being “reachable” at all times has invaded traditional boundaries. We've normalized a culture where being off the clock almost feels irresponsible. Even our friendships have adapted to this normality where texting, reacting to stories, and leaving comments have replaced deeper conversations, and yet we still call it connection. 

She then described a number of ways she has tried to manage digital overload in her own life. She concludes: 

Each of us has the power to redefine our relationship with technology. It starts with recognizing the need for balance and then taking even the smallest steps to disconnect. As I continue down this journey, I encourage others to do the same. To reflect on their own relationship with technology and consider how they, too, can reclaim peace.

Obviously, this course did not provide me with enough data from which to make generalizations about everyone in Generation Z. Still, I can confidently say that my experience does--to my satisfaction at least--debunk the idea that young people will not engage legacy media. In private interactions, students told me that have never been hostile to established sources of information like the NYT. Rather, those sources do not show up in social media algorithms, and if they do they too often have information restricted behind a paywall.  

Wednesday, May 07, 2025

Media Rants Video May 7, 2025: Papal Bull?

 

Thursday, May 01, 2025

An Open Letter to President Obama

An audio version of this Media Rant can be found here.

Note: From 2009-2017, Barack Obama served as the 44th President of the United States. Though I voted for him twice, his presidency disappointed and frustrated me. I don't usually seek out insights from the actor Matt Damon, but I thought he was spot-on when in 2011 he said that Obama had "misinterpreted his mandate" and failed to follow through on the significant changes voters were looking for. It is true of course that the Republicans openly obstructed everything Obama tried to do, but even that I thought could have been overcome if he had used his exceptional political skills to rally the masses in support of fundamental change.   

Now I know that the latest Democratic Party rhetoric is all about "the future," and I get the school of thought that says it is time to make a break from all of yesterday's Dems, including Obama. The counter to that view is that Barack Obama is one of the few national level Democrats capable of dominating more than one news cycle. In 2007 and 2008 his ability to inspire was needed to help Americans find hope during the disastrous second term of President George W. Bush. In 2025 the disaster of the second Trump term makes George Dubya's failures look like innocent mistakes. Maybe it's time for Obama to work the magic again? 

Here's how he can do it: 

Illinois Senator Richard Durbin recently announced he would not seek another term in 2026. That  provides an opening for President Obama to get off the sidelines and back in the game. I think he should once again run for the United States Senate from Illinois (he represented Illinois in the US Senate from 2005-2008), and after he gets elected the Democrats should immediately choose him to replace Chuck Schumer as leader.  Even the act of campaigning for the seat would provide Obama with a legitimate platform from which to educate the population about the true-threat of Trumpism, and once again provide hope. I'll lay out more of my reasons for thinking Obama should run in the open letter below. 

Dear President Obama: 

I hope this letter finds you well. As you know, Senator Richard Durbin of Illinois announced recently that he will not be seeking reelection in 2026. I'm writing to ask you to run for that seat. When you win, the Democrats should immediately move to make you their leader in the US Senate.  I understand that former presidents running for Congress after they leave office is rare, and that throwing your hat in the Illinois ring would be considered extraordinary. But we are living in extraordinary times; a civic emergency the likes of which we have not seen since the 1860s. The Trump Administration's extraordinary disregard for, and dismantling of, the US Constitution requires an extraordinary response from the opposition. 

Before dismissing my plea out of hand, please consider my three reasons why you should run: We need hope, we need unity, and we need congressional leadership. 

First, We Need Hope:  Your 2004 DNC Keynote Speech, along with your presidential campaign rhetoric of 2008 and 2012, inspired hope in a way that was and is unprecedented in modern American history. When you visited the college campus where I teach (the University of Wisconsin Oshkosh), your appearance was the first and ONLY time the majority of my students asked if they could skip class to see a political speaker--without me having to offer any extra credit. They came back "fired up and ready to go."  

Of course you are not the only contemporary political actor able to inspire hope. But you are the only one who would be able to spread the message of hope daily, and get nonstop coverage in broadcast and social media while doing so. Just as important, you would inspire hope candidates to run for local, state, and national offices all over the country.   

Second, We Need Unity: Even as the Trump Administration demolishes everything that made America great--from the guarantee of due process to trusting the judgement of The People over a King--the Democrats remain hopelessly divided. Too many Democrats with national stature seem more interested in occupying the "progressive lane" or the "moderate lane" or the "rural lane" than in doing the hard work of uniting the factions against a common and dangerous foe. In your first inaugural address you quoted the immortal words of George Washington, which are even more relevant now: "Let it be told to the future world . . . that in the depth of winter, when nothing but hope and virtue could survive . . . that the city and country, alarmed at one common danger, came forth to meet [it]." 

Third, We Need Congressional Leadership: With all due respect to Senator Schumer, he is not the Senate leader the Democrats need at this point in history, when the risk of losing our democracy is no longer just hypothetical. You are one of the most popular politicians in America. Given your stature not just as a former president, but also as a former United States Senator from Illinois, you would be able to fight to restore the rule of checks and balances to our federal government in a way that no other politician can. With you as an elected leader in the United States Senate, we will get the Obama v. Trump debates that the presidential term limits did not allow. I am confident that not only will you win those debates, but will role model for the citizenry how to stand up to Trumpism effectively.  

As you know, President John Quincy Adams got elected to the House of Representatives after he left the White House. From 1831 until his death in 1848, Adams was the most principled, articulate foe of slavery in the Congress. He once said that " . . a Constitution of government once changed from freedom, can never be restored. Liberty, once lost, is lost forever." As we see our liberty slipping away in real time, we need a new JQ Adams to be the principled, articulate voice of freedom in the Congress. That new JQ is you. 

Allow me to close by asserting that I realize the Democrats' general aversion to anything labeled "crazy" makes it difficult for them to entertain even the possibility of what I am suggesting in this letter. But I know that you admired the late civil rights movement icon, the Reverend Joseph Lowery, who taught us that in the struggle for justice there is "good crazy" and "bad crazy."  You've also many times sparked citizen activism by citing Dr. King's assertion of "the fierce urgency of now." The fierce urgency of now requires Barack Obama to get off the sidelines and back on the political field. 

Would President Obama entering the race for US Senate from Illinois provoke a media feeding frenzy? Yes. Would your return to formal electoral politics generate a Hollywood level of drama and theatricality? Yes. But would your entry into the race demonstrate your commitment--and the commitment of your Party-- to "walking the walk" on saving our democracy in a way that no other action can? Also yes. Your announcement of a campaign to run for the US Senate is the "good crazy" we need right now. 

Please take this plea seriously. Your country needs you.  

Sincerely, 

Tony Palmeri 

Tuesday, April 29, 2025

Media Rants Video: The Real Ink Crisis?

Friday, April 25, 2025

Media Rants Video Podcast

I'm playing around with making a video version of Media Rants to complement the blog.  As time permits, I'm planning to interview some guests to talk about media, as well as offer up my own solo rants. The first episode is on the Wisconsin Media's pretty dreadful coverage of the NFL Draft in Green Bay: